Are Attacks on Trans Rights Also Attacks on Women’s Liberation?

1. Because men's prison is not safe for trans mtf, it doesn't equate trans mtf being safe for women in the female prison.
   Does the violence in men's prison stop once trans mtf are transferred to women's prison? No, it doesn't and the women's prison should not be shelter for vulnerable men just because men's prison is a violent pecking order.

2. No !! but trans rights are definitely an attack on women's rights ! Sports, washrooms, jails , women shelters, etc are ALL IN DANGER because of trans women. This is a FACT !!!

3. This criminally psycho ogre is going to jail soon! Hip hip!

4. reads title ….I'll never understand why people compare two things with little to no correlation.

5. @00:18 it clearly states that they wish to define SEX as male or female, there is nothing on there about gender. @16:55 there is not a grey area between who is male or female, males produce sperm and females produce eggs, that’s how humans reproduce.Also it is obvious that in our society women are oppressed, the fact that men who think they’re women are telling actual women we can not define ourselves that men who feel they are women now define womanhood should attest to that fact.

6. This is dumb.

7. If someone believes they are Napolean, should they be treated as if they are Napolean, and exiled to Malba? If someone believes they are Jesus, should they be treated as if they are Jesus, and crucified? If someone believes they are a cat, should everyone pet and stroke them and tease them with toys? This is ridiculous.

8. Why is freedom and equality such a difficult concept for so many people to grasp? The march of progress is a consistent story of people who support freedom and equality against those that want to create and perpetuate second-class statuses and increase inequality because they think equality is oppression of their "right" to own slaves, own their wife, sit in a particular section of the bus, use a special "clean" waterfountain, call the police to arrest anyone not conforming to gender norms or using drugs different from the ones they use. Their fear drives them to justify their endless desire to control anything or anyone they don't like by lumping them in with criminals or the diseased. They'll even try to stop free adults from accessing books, music, video games, any media that offends their sensitive sensibilities, even if they disavow those that do call for such blatant censorship, they're not on team freedom if they're calling for the oppression of rights of a group of people who have committed no harm or violation against another person.

9. "Mischa" made certain to BLAME every other movement, individual, and group for the Transgender community's problems EXCEPT the Transgender community itself.

10. Women aren't men. Women isn't a gender, it literally means adult human female. Women are oppressed specifically because of our biology. Gender isn't what's being oppressed. Gender is the grooming tool of masculinity/femininity . Gender is not a binary, gender NEVER was a binary. Gender is a HIERARCHY. Gender is not a natural construct created by each individual. Gender is an IMPOSED social construct. It's not subjective nor innate ie gender is not your inner personality. It's an IMPOSED set of stereotypical social roles of behaviour/performance/interests, to categorize people into who is dominate/subordinate, superior/inferior based on their biological sex.
    The motive of gender in our society is intentional and is a conscious construct by those who actually have power in how society is run (this group does not include most people and certainly isn't dictated nor can it be socially constructed by any one of the millions of regular citizens, living their lives because none of us here and myself included, have the institutional power to implement anything that will structure how our society shall be run).There actually is a motive behind this creation of the social construct that is gender, with categorizing people based on biological sex as superior/inferior. The motive is one of oppression of female people as a group for the material exploitation of reproductive sex.
    Females birth the bodies for the next round of human resources for a globalized capitalist society on the whole. We birth the bodies of soldiers to implement it's imperialist expansion, we birth the working class wage slave workers, we birth the slave workers in sweatshops if we are unfortunate to be born in the third world, we birth the next generation of indigenous (if we ourselves are indigenous) in which land capitalists want to steal and exploit land resources for profit, so we have to be forced sterilized so that we eventually wont exist as a barrier to access those land resources. We are forced/coerced to pick up the slack by working FOR FREE ie house slavery and maintain these household duties as well as the care takers of the next round of those to be exploited later on (child care rearing) ie housewifization, so it frees up the men to be able to have more time, more hours, to go to work, to be exploitable for longer periods. Because they have said handmaiden to do all the life maintenance, so that those who are owners of capitalist enterprises, don't lose out in surplus profit by giving workers time off to maintain life outside of their work. If we are lesbians (female homosexuality; same sex orientated) by our very existence, agitates the ideology of the nuclear family unit (a miniature version of the social hierarchy with men being head of household and where housewifization can take place) which also doesn't reproduce the desired control of human resources, in and of itself (two females don't reproduce children ie exploitable human resources)
    ………. What is the main motive behind "trans" oppression constructed institutionally for exploitation of resources/gains? Other than their ideology which creates naval gazing narcissism based on superficial individual appearances and a choice of personal style? LOL Gender identity ideology correlates very suspiciously with capitalist consumerism and choice in options (options which only drives up surplus profit for capitalists and in which aren't in any way created out of a basic need) Are people who are and believe in trans/gender identity discriminated against? I think any gender non conforming person probably would experience discrimination, but discrimination is not oppression (oppression is socially constructed for specific groups for the set purpose of material exploitation needed to maintain a social hierarchy, thus is based on objective material reality, NOT a subjective inner feeling)
    Women are women. Transwomen are men because they are, in reality, human males. Do transwomen face violence from men who are gender conforming? Yes. But are transwomen less violent than ordinary male people? There's no evidence to suggest they are less violent and there's evidence also to suggest they still statistically are violent to women. Women didn't create the issue of masculinity and the male violence associated with that and are today not in a position to fix this. How about men have a conversation and spaces made amongst themselves to solve the fact that they keep killing each other, and are socialized into being physically/sexually violent and aggressive? This is not our issue as women to try to fix or focus upon especially when those men who "identify" as women demand our universal compliance to access all spaces, validate the lie that men are women because they are feminine and "identify" as a member of the opposite sex, basically remove the ability to speak on issues pertaining to biological sex (because it doesn't include transwomen) even though our biological sex is the root cause of why society oppresses us.

11. Transgender children ?

    That’s child abuse

12. I use to support TRNN a few years back until I realized they covered almost nothing Trans or LGBT. Now after reading all TRNN's hate filled fascism followers I feel even less of a reason to support this cisgender bias news outlet. We'll survive, and just like last time without much if any reporting on trans people from TRNN.

13. Looks like the trolls sure came out on this video.

14. forgot to include the oppressed people of size wow…what a hatemonger

15. the thumbnail is amazing

16. More bull! Trans wasn't medically excepted until Oboma pushed for it. Medically speaking, the trans transformation doesn't exist! Men and women are born genetically different! The medical community is setting themselves up for legal ramifications in the future! We are feeding these people drugs that WILL hinder their health. The trans kids? Please don't do this to a child! We don't know the long term effects of drugging a chlids body like this! It might be a death sentence. I fear for the quality of life of these people.

17. Mischa Haider I don't want men using my daughters bathroom or locker. Especially ones with conditions of a sexual nature.

18. is peanut butter the same as jam?

    separating yourselves until its warranted, for sheer personal gain.
    great tactic!! equality is non-existent in this exercise.

19. Transgender is the only psychological condition we celebrate. All the others we treat.

20. Umm I don't understand the first few seconds. Because of patriarchy women need spaces away from men, including men who say they are women. Please look up this never happens. Sex has chromosomal and gonadal presentation. This person shows his thinking to be muddy like the turd JP. Biology is not bigotry.

21. Sex is no a feeling. Trans rights would mean the right to safety, housing, and freedom from job discrimination. It does not mean biological males have the right to spaces meant for biological females. The trans movement as it stands is misogynistic and a danger to women and girls. Many feminist and womens organizations are being harassed and even assaulted for saying this. The real news and other left wing media in the US needs to be honest and allow gender critical women speak on this.

22. We've ALWAYS BEEN LIBERATED but didn't have to work outside the HOME. Had tons of respect but the Jewish communists wanted the other 50% to pay taxes, indoctrinate the children & turn men into porn watching idiots.

23. Sex is a continuum. Gender is a continuum. Sexual orientation is a continuum. Trump is showing bullying ignorance, not leadership. Trump is a dictator wannabe, not a president of al. people. Violence happens when people are held under the thumb of ignorant dictators. Depression happens when people are held under the thumb of ignorant dictators.

24. yes

25. People born with front poles are male.
    People born with front holes are female.

26. I'm not opposed to people choosing to change their sex, but this very rare occurrence (look at the stats) is so overrepresented in the media and academia that it is hard not to suspect a nefarious agenda and politicization of a phenomenon that affects a tiny fraction of the population — a tiny fraction that is considerably smaller than the larger gay and lesbian community (it's one thing to be gay or lesbian; it's another thing to be trangender; the tendentious LBGT name and movement wants us to believe they are all the same, which they are not).

    Wall Street is well-known for funding the unnecessary narcissism of attention-seeking transgender activists, whose alleged victimhood pales in comparison with segments of the population in the world who deserve far more attention than they do; surely, it is not from the kindness of their heart Wall Street is so eager to put this movement on life support (perhaps, rather 'divide et impera'). Not to mention that, among the tiny fraction of transgender people on the planet, a number of them end up regretting changing their sex:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-pxxBQm114k

    Much ado about nothing. I appreciate RealNews' coverage on a number of issues, but your thumbs down on this video are well-deserved.

27. TRUMP 2020

28. Even the climate change video brought out fewer ignorant, bigoted, and scientifically illiterate people in this comment section. Gender is a dial not a switch. The science is in. End.

29. ®™ TMALX Transnational 🌏 Militant💥 Armed🔫Liberation⛓ Xecutive🕶 Observation ✍ ✍✍

    Attacks on ANYONE'S rights is an attack on EVERYONE'S rights.
    Think that way !!!!

30. ®™ TMALX Transnational 🌏 Militant💥 Armed🔫Liberation⛓ Xecutive🕶 Observation ✍ ✍✍

    Attacks on ANYONE'S rights is an attack on EVERYONE'S rights.
    Think that way !!!!

31. fascism will eventually attack everything that doesn't precisely mirror itself

32. it's time to stop.

33. Women and our rights have absolutely nothing to do with trans people so dont even try it!

Comments are closed.